Let me start this by saying I think the ring of wealth is a really fun item. When I find one in any of my runs, I immediately get excited. That is, for all of 5 minutes before I realise I feel obligated to play a RoW run, sinking at least a dozen hours of mindless grinding into becoming God. In short, RoW is far too powerful, and so ruins both the fun and challenge of the game. Now I know what you’re thinking :
If you don’t like the item then simply don’t use it, why ruin everyone else’s fun?
And that makes sense initially until you realise that finding a RoW in say a crystal chest is just a complete let down if you don’t want to use it. Not to mention the fact that I KNOW that I’m not the only one who feels dread when faced with an early RoW. This is why the solution of disabling it in runs where challenges are active makes the most sense to me. The overwhelming odds are that people who play the game to simply make fun powerful builds play without challenges, and people who play the game for the expertly crafted challenge it poses play with challenges enabled. This has the added bonus of making the super hard badges like 1mill score actualy hard rather than the majority of people feeling the need to cheese it with the RoW. As for the problem of this being an unituitive change, a simple pop-up the first time players select challenges explaining their general idea and this change should suffice. A rework of its mechanics could also be a viable solution, shifting it to focus more on rare loot drops over the boring and grind inducing drop rate multiplier.
Another reason that RoW is a problem, though I’ll admit perhaps one only 00-evan will have to consider, is that it’s very limiting of design space. As an example for this, I recently tried designing some new sub-classes for the game, just for fun. One such sub-class revolved around their powers magnitude being tied to either alchemical energy or unique alchemical crafts. Clearly, gaining even a slightly upgraded RoW with this sub-class would be fundamentally overpowered. It’s not just this example either, it’s very easy to imagine a world where a cool new feature being considered added to the game would be unbalanceable around the RoW.
At the end of the day, this is all just my opinion and a suggestion, please contribute with your own opinions on the matter, or just shout at me about why I’m wrong :p. As the Civ IV devs famously said: “Given the opportunity, players will optimise the fun out of a game.”
Firstly, thanks for the feedback! I’m sort of split on this, because on one hand I agree with your dislike of farming, and personally would prefer if there was absolutely 0 farming possibility in the game, but I have to balance that against some players really enjoying farming gameplay. So, the ring of wealth and wand of regrowth are two sort of ‘dedicated farming’ items, where spending enough upgrades into them makes it fairly easy to farm indefinitely.
I don’t ever want this to become a meta strategy though, but I really don’t think that’s the case as you’re describing it. Analytics data isn’t infallible of course, but I do keep track of item success rates, and wealth/regrowth are consistently some of the lowest winrate items in their categories (with the exception of the obvious huntress/warden regrowth synergy). Tedious as it may be, I think getting a farming win with so many challenges is still a reasonable reflection of your skill, and not purely the power of wealth farming.
I’m pretty happy leaving my +2 or even +0 RoW unupgraded. It is one of the best rings in the game even without farming. Even at +0 you get tons of gold and consumables.
An item that is the most powerfull ring in the game at only +2 shouldn’t be in the game
It is one of the best at +2, I’d rather have a +3 haste.
I disagree that ring of wealth is as powerful as you are making it out to be. Also, it seems like half of your motivation to make this change is because you can’t resist the temptation of a RoW run when presented with the opportunity.
Every time I see a person who grinded for hours and hours to get hundreds of every type of consumable, I see a run that probably would have been easier to win with that ring of wealth left at +1 and the SoUs invested into more straightforward strategies.
My highest successful RoW run was 7 challenges, and I HATED that run - it took forever, and I had to play carefully for so much longer than a conventional run. The others times I tried a RoW run at 6+ challenges, I died before I could reap the benefits of the ring of wealth or made a mistake while grinding and died.
Like someone else said here, I would take a ring of haste over wealth any day. I advise most of the people on this sub that ring of wealth is a trap - leave it at +0 or +1 like you would with most other rings.
i might just suck harder than i realized, because I cant get the thing to work on challenge runs. Ive found one early a few times, but the risk/reward from dumping sou doesnt pay off before I get merkd from not having upgraded gear.
edit:case in point. badder bosses and hostile champs. granted i shouldnt have been trying to wear an unidentified ring, and got very unlucky getting surrounded in a hallway trying to kite a blessed goo. still, i would rather have had a +3 ring of punching really hard
Skill issue /s. In all seriousness ive had lots of sucess with RoW in challenges. Its how i got the 1mill badge the first time. People who can’t get RoW to work on challenge runs wont miss ots absence though i would assume?
Frankly, no I wouldn’t miss it at this point.
If you need to be a really strong player to make it work in challenge runs (and you have no problems winning without RoW) then I don’t really see the problem. I, personally, don’t bother upgrading RoW because I have no interest in grinding when I can just go win the game instead. If you take all the scrolls you would otherwise put into RoW and dump them into a ring of sharpshooting instead you’ll have a much easier time just blowing things up with 50 damage boomerangs.
While I can appreciate the sentiment “And that makes sense initially until you realise that finding a RoW in say a crystal chest is just a complete let down if you don’t want to use it.” that seems like a bad reason to want the ring removed from the game. I hate getting ring of sharpshooting. It’s my least favorite ring of the game but there is no need to remove it. I just transmute it or more likely sell it and hope for something better next time. What isn’t fun for you is a lot of fun for other people. Choosing NOT to dump SoU on the ring seems like it solves the problem.
I still don’t know how to put in so many hours of grinding when the thing stops working as soon as you don’t get any more XP.
The way the game works is that enemies stop dropping items 2 levels after they stop giving exp, allowing you to farm them when you are in that level range
Hey. I love RoW. If you hate it so much, transmute it. Don’t try and rob me of a ring I never seem to get.
Thing to note RoW runs are impossible with FIMA. So just play with that.
Edit: Tried it, I was wrong lol
In all fairness I haven’t done a RoW run with FiMA, but I have done a fair bit of farming with FiMA and other chals, I see no reason I couldn’t do much the same thing with RoW
Not true, I have had successful RoW runs with 7 challenges including FiMA
![[Shattered] RoW needs to be either removed from challenge runs, reworked, or simply removed from the game (imo), a discussion](https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/dd8463ba-e268-4ed8-8735-7ff7992f970d.png){kind=link}