cross-posted from: https://geddit.social/post/460263

I generally enjoy all anime songs but what I enjoy more are those anime songs that have a vibe similar to that of western music.

Personally I consider typical anime songs to have one or any combination of the following tones: optimistic, childish, adventurous, cheering, mischievous. This is understandable as most animes depict stories of ‘ideal’ worlds or non-existent universes with supernatural beings and/or powers.

I feel like western songs are more realistic. They sing around something that is experienced by almost everyone. They have a tone that could be incorporated as background music to certain life situations without feeling out of place. Maybe it is pretty obvious since they are not created for animated forms of media, but are different nonetheless.

I am in search for songs that have the best of both worlds. Songs from anime openings or endings (maybe even from the OST) which have a more realistic or ‘cinematic’ vibe like that of western music.

Some examples I could provide to get you the general of what I am talking about are:

  1. All ‘Attack on Titan’ openings except ‘Red Swan’
  2. Akuma no Ko (Attack on Titan Ed7)
  3. Mukanjyo (Vinland Saga Op1)
  4. CHAINSAW BLOOD (Chainsaw Man Ed1)
  5. First Death (Chainsaw Man Ed7)
  6. VIOLENCE (Chainsaw Man Ed11)
  7. Hydra (Overlord Ed2)
  8. Silent Solitude (Overlord Ed3)
  9. VORACITY (Overlord Op3)
  10. Vivid Vice (Jujustu Kaisen Op2)

Few disclaimers:

  1. I am not a big anime fan, so it’s reasonable that my examples are pretty limited.
  2. No, I don’t love rock to have majority of the above songs in that genre. I like songs by One Direction and Taylor Swift too, but I could not find an equivalent song from any anime I watched so far.
  3. I won’t consider what the lyrics say. They may be in Japanese or English or both and may have a completely opposite theme to the song, but the song itself is what I am looking for.
  • hitagiAEnglish
    8·
    11 months ago

    I think the cheerful (maybe “idealist”) anime soundtrack are associated with anime that convey the same themes (highschool life, idol shows, some shounen, some isekai, etc) so you need to watch more shows that convey different themes. You’ve mentioned soundtracks from Overlord, JJK, CSM, and AoT, all of which have varying degrees of grim tone and have, frankly, a lot of “action” (which is paired with “cinematic” music).

    I think a lot of 90s anime soundtrack can fit the bill. Check out the OSTs of Cowboy Bebop, Serial Experiments Lain, Neon Genesis Evangelion, and Beserk. Cowboy Bebop is pretty much jazz. SEL and NGE both feature songs that are in English (Duvet and Komm Susser Todd). NGE and Berserk have incredibly good “cinematic” music.

    Anyway, I don’t think “Western” is the correct term here. I honestly think “realistic” is a poor descriptor for some of the soundtrack you’ve mentioned especially when you mentioned that lyrics don’t matter. There’s a lot of anime feature-length and series that have Western-like music.