Proton is the Future of PC gaming. But how does it work?
youtu.be
It’s clear there are some people who don’t understand Proton. So let’s talk about it. #Proton #SteamPlay #CompatibilityLayerPatrons get beta access to my new...

cross-posted from: https://beehaw.org/post/16434132

YouTube video: https://youtu.be/uScsmjvdwyo

Invidious video from YouTube without YouTube: https://inv.nadeko.net/watch?v=uScsmjvdwyo or https://invidious.nerdvpn.de/watch?v=uScsmjvdwyo

Video description:

It’s clear there are some people who don’t understand Proton. So let’s talk about it. #Proton #SteamPlay #CompatibilityLayer

00:00 Introduction
00:41 The basics of a computer
01:46 What Proton is not
03:04 What is an emulator
04:32 Proton acts like a map
05:25 Proton translates API and system calls
06:18 Proton provides a Windows-like software environment
06:55 Why are some games incompatible?
08:52 Shouldn't we demand native Linux games?
11:07 Conclusion
    • Björn Tantau@swg-empire.de
      351·
      2 months ago

      Sadly this has more or less died with unmaintained games. It’s a pain the arse to get old native games working. And for many titles the Windows version with Proton works much better than the Linux native one. Win32 has somehow become the most stable Linux API.

        • Björn Tantau@swg-empire.de
          232·
          2 months ago

          I know, I have many of them. Most of them I specifically bought when they got Linux support, like Tomb Raider and Alien Isolation.

          Not a single commercial game runs as well natively as it does through Proton. Tomb Raider - has much worse graphics. Alien Isolation - for some reason the DPad doesn’t work. Baldur’s Gate - I have to supply some old openssl (or so, can’t remember) library. And I shudder at the thought of trying to get Unreal Tournament 2004 or Doom 3 (not the open source version) running. I should try to dig out my disc for Ankh to see how hard it is to get that one running.

          Maintained games and especially open source ones run great. But the sad reality is that it costs money to maintain software. Linux backwards compatibility is abysmal. It is much easier to get a 20 year old Windows game to run than a 20 year old Linux game.

          Though to be fair, it is also hard on Windows to get a 20 year old Windows game to run. Wine is just a great piece of software.

          I would love to have more native games. My own game is native as well. And luckily most indie devs usually also bring out a native port. And still most of the time the Windows version via Proton just runs better.

          • Fubarberry@sopuli.xyzOPMEnglish
            7·
            2 months ago

            Yeah, wine is incredible for preservation. Many older games don’t work on either platform (old windows games on windows, old linux games on linux), but running old windows games through proton usually works great.

          • woelkchen@lemmy.world
            39·
            2 months ago

            Not a single commercial game runs as well natively as it does through Proton.

            It’s funny when people like you make such statements because someone needs to literally name just a one commercial game and you’re already being proven a liar. OK, I start: Selaco.

            But the sad reality is that it costs money to maintain software.

            So what? They should stop taking money for unmaintained games then.

            • FooBarrington@lemmy.world
              9·
              2 months ago

              The guy said he bought games, and those don’t work as well natively. You can list games all you want, if he didn’t buy them it won’t change his experience.

              So what? They should stop taking money for unmaintained games then.

              Yeah, fuck those Linux users! Only sell those games to Windows users! That will help Linux market share :)

              • woelkchen@lemmy.world
                21·
                2 months ago

                The guy said he bought games, and those don’t work as well natively.

                No, he didn’t say “those”. He made a statement about commercial Linux games in general (edit: in a separate paragraph).

                if he didn’t buy them it won’t change his experience.

                Shouldn’t make a generalized statement like that then.

                Yeah, fuck those Linux users! Only sell those games to Windows users!

                No idea how you get to that from my statement that’s advocating to make unmaintained games free. 🤷

                • FooBarrington@lemmy.world
                  2·
                  2 months ago

                  No, he didn’t say “those”. He made a statement about commercial Linux games in general.

                  When a normal person talks about a topic, they don’t have to continuously clarify that they still talk about the same topic, it’s assumed.

                  He mentioned that he has a bunch of Linux native games. The commercial ones run worse compared to running under Proton. This isn’t complicated. Accept that you misunderstood and move on.

                  No idea how you get to that from my statement that’s advocating to make unmaintained games free. 🤷

                  Oh, now we interpret according to the intent of the author?

                  • woelkchen@lemmy.world
                    11·
                    2 months ago

                    When a normal person talks about a topic, they don’t have to continuously clarify that they still talk about the same topic, it’s assumed.

                    It’s a new statement in a new paragraph.

                    Oh, now we interpret according to the intent of the author?

                    Accept that you misunderstood and move on.

      • woelkchen@lemmy.world
        36·
        2 months ago

        Win32 has somehow become the most stable Linux API.

        Windows is a moving target. Wine/Proton is a reverse engineering chase of a moving target. WINDOWS GAMES ON PROTON BREAK ALL THE TIME! Stop making stuff. It’s great that Proton exists but it’s not like Java. What does not break? Flatpak Runtimes and Steam Linux Runtime.

        • woelkchen@lemmy.world
          22·
          2 months ago

          Linux is a total pain in the behind to write applications for, because of API and ABI instability.

          Flatpak

      • Fubarberry@sopuli.xyzOPMEnglish
        5·
        2 months ago

        Yeah, can’t get market share without games, but it’s hard to get games without marketshare. Proton made sure we have games, now we need marketshare. Once we have marketshare we’ll get more high quality linux native ports (I hope).

      • woelkchen@lemmy.world
        41·
        2 months ago

        Proton is the gateway drug to us getting more Linux native games.

        It’s not when Win32 apologists keep making insane claims how stable Proton is… “Proton is great, it just runs all the Windows games” is the mess that got us to the place where games we buy just start crashing suddenly because nobody of those developers realizes that each major release of Proton must be treated like its own OS with proper QA targeting that. Proton works great for old games because these old games no longer change. For modern games that still get updates Proton is a gamble because a reverse engineered version of the Windows API just isn’t stable.

      • Neshura@bookwormstory.socialEnglish
        2·
        2 months ago

        in my experience that usually boils down to the Linux version getting (an understandably) low priority compared to the windows version. Which is something that won’t change until Linux has a significant market share and I can’t fault the devs for it. For an example of a game where that is not the case I’d like to take Factorio, where the devs went out of their way to properly work on the Linux native version and even include Linux/Mac exclusive features for their next update. But that only happened because one of the devs themselves uses Linux.